top of page

Sourcing Original Materials in Restoration: Stone, Mortar and Joinery

5 days ago
7 min read

On a restoration site the work usually slows down after the scaffolding goes up. The stonemason has arrived, the scaffold is ready, the project is approved. But nobody knows which quarry the stone in the wall came from, the binder in the mortar has not been established, and there is no dimension for the window joinery profile. Those three gaps translate into months.

In restoration, procurement looks like a purchasing department task and is in fact a conservation decision. Which stone, which mortar and which timber are used determines whether the original fabric survives. This article sets out the sequence that makes that decision possible.

Diagnosis before order

Placing something new without knowing the existing material is like buying shoes without measuring a foot. In a restoration file that work is called material analysis, and it answers three questions: what this material is, which decay process it is in, and which properties the replacement must carry.

For stone, three data sets are needed: petrographic description, physical properties and condition. Petrographic examination establishes mineral composition, texture and pore structure, and TS EN 12407 is the standard used for petrographic examination of natural stone. On the physical side the relevant tests are uniaxial compressive strength, water absorption at atmospheric pressure, real and apparent density with open porosity, and frost resistance, defined in TS EN 1926, TS EN 13755, TS EN 1936 and TS EN 12371 respectively.

For mortar the questions are different. Is the binder lime, hydraulic lime or a blend; what is the aggregate grading; what is the binder to aggregate ratio; is there cement in it; what is the salt content. Those answers come from thin section petrography, X ray diffraction and fluorescence, acid dissolution and thermal analysis. The laboratory can choose the method. The project author has to write the questions.

For joinery, species, section, profile geometry and existing joints are established. Species is identified by anatomical examination; section and profile are measured in place. In metal joinery the same file records whether the material is wrought or cast, the corrosion condition and the structure of the existing paint layers.

Translating conservation principles into procurement language

International conservation doctrine has already drawn the frame for material decisions. Article 9 of the Venice Charter states that restoration is based on respect for original material and authentic documents and must stop at the point where conjecture begins. Article 10 allows modern technique where traditional techniques prove inadequate, but only where its efficacy has been shown by scientific data and proved by experience. Article 12 requires replacements of missing parts to integrate harmoniously with the whole while remaining distinguishable from the original.

Those three sentences become three concrete rules in procurement.

First, unproven convenience is not allowed. A product that sets quickly, bonds to every surface and reaches high strength in a short time is usually the wrong choice on a historic wall, because a historic wall moves, breathes and carries salt. Placing a hard, vapour tight layer behind porous stone does not stop decay. It pushes decay to the surface.

Second, distinguishability is a requirement, not a defect. New stone does not have to look like the old stone next to it, and should not pretend to. It does have to be compatible. That balance is reached through the right stone and the right surface treatment, not through imitating colour and texture.

Third, every intervention is designed to be reversible. That applies to pointing, surface cleaning and consolidation. An irreversible treatment cannot be corrected when better information arrives later.

Stone supply: quarry matching is not a coincidence

Stone in historic buildings usually came from quarries nearby. The first place to look is therefore the traditional quarries in the region. Stone from the same formation behaves closest to the original in mineral composition and pore structure.

Colour comparison alone is not enough when matching a quarry. The list to compare is: mineralogical composition, open porosity, water absorption, compressive strength, frost resistance and salt behaviour. Those figures are assessed by placing the analysis of a sample from the existing stone next to the analysis of a sample from the candidate quarry.

Three traps recur. The first is that different beds in the same quarry behave differently, so samples are taken from at least two locations in the candidate quarry. The second is that the surface treatment applied at the quarry may imitate the original texture rather than match it; cutting direction and surface finish are project decisions. The third is that lead time depends on quarry capacity, so for a restoration scale job the quarry schedule is asked for before the site schedule.

Quarry operating permits and documents belong in the supply file too. Stone from an unlicensed quarry has no traceability, and material without traceability causes problems at inspection.

Mortar: ask for the reasoning, not the ratio

Mortar is the most argued and most often mishandled item in restoration, largely because mix recipes travel by word of mouth. The correct approach is not to memorise a recipe but to analyse the existing mortar and define a mix that matches it.

On the binder side, TS EN 459-1 classifies building lime products by definitions, specifications and conformity criteria. On the aggregate side, TS EN 13139 defines aggregates for mortar. Those two standards also set the language of the documents requested from a supplier: which class the product belongs to, which declaration accompanies delivery, and how batch traceability is established.

The mix ratio itself is a decision for the project author, based on the analysis and on manufacturer data. No ratio is given in this article, and that is a principle rather than an omission: a ratio without a source and a justification gets applied on site without debate and becomes one of the most expensive things to correct later.

Three technical headings are asked about specifically. The first is vapour permeability; lime based mortar allows stone to dry. The second is elasticity; historic walls move slightly and a very hard mortar accumulates that movement as cracks in the stone. The third is salt content; salts entering from the mortar appear later as efflorescence and scaling on the stone surface.

Joinery: measure the profile, identify the species

With timber joinery the first task is measuring the existing profile. Section, sash thickness, glazing rebate, hinge position and joint detail are drawn, and that drawing is the production reference. The second task is anatomical species identification, because two species that look alike behave differently outdoors.

The third task is establishing moisture and condition. Which part of the existing joinery is replaced, which is repaired and which is kept as it is depends on measurement and a decay map. For new sections the grain direction, the position of the joint and the adhesive type are each defined.

In metal joinery the wrought and cast distinction determines the repair method. Wrought iron can be repaired by forging; cast iron is brittle and often requires reproduction. Welding on historic metal raises questions of heat effect and corrosion behaviour, and should not be applied without a project decision.

What the supplier file contains

A well built supplier file leaves no questions at inspection. It holds the material definition and class, the manufacturer declaration, batch and shipment traceability, analysis reports, trial results, and application and maintenance information.

Part of that file is a trial application. The rule that production does not start before an approved sample has been seen on site applies to stone, mortar and joinery alike. A one square metre trial panel shows the colour and texture of a ten thousand square metre facade in advance. Approval of that panel is recorded in writing and the panel is kept on site.

Site acceptance: what happens after delivery

When material arrives, the task is not signing a delivery note. Three checks apply.

The first is identity: is the delivered material the same as the approved sample and the definition in the supply file. The second is batch separation: different batches are not mixed, because batches from the same quarry or production run can behave differently. The third is storage: lime is protected from moisture, timber from sun and from the ground, and stone from contact with salt bearing ground.

Any material change made on site that falls outside the approved project is a fresh approval subject. Article 10 of Law No. 2863 provides that the conservation, implementation and supervision offices are obliged to carry out supervision, including the project and material changes approved by the regional conservation boards. A material decision is not free space in site practice.

Obligations and support on the owner side

Article 11 of Law No. 2863 provides that owners of immovable cultural and natural assets benefit from the rights and exemptions granted to owners where they carry out maintenance and repair in accordance with the orders and instructions issued by the Ministry. Article 12 provides for in kind, cash and technical assistance by the Ministry for the protection, maintenance and repair of immovable cultural and natural assets owned by private individuals and legal entities.

The practical consequence for an owner is that once the process is documented, both the obligation and the support become visible in the same file. A record showing that maintenance and repair followed the instruction is also useful in any dispute that arises later.

FAQ

Is stone from the nearest quarry always the right choice?

It is often the closest solution, but not sufficient on its own. Even within the same formation, different beds can show different porosity and strength. The decision is made by comparing sample analyses.

Should existing mortar be removed and replaced?

Not every joint is renewed. Sound and compatible joints are retained, and deteriorated joints are renewed with a mix compatible with the original mortar. Removing every joint means both a loss of original material and unnecessary intervention in the wall.

Why is cement containing mortar debated?

Because of its hardness, low vapour permeability and salt behaviour, which can push decay to the surface when it is used with porous historic stone. Declaring it prohibited in every case would still be wrong; the decision follows the analysis of the existing material and the nature of the intervention.

Which parts of joinery are replaced?

Measurement and the decay map show which part is structural and which is infill. Decayed splice pieces are usually replaced and sound frames repaired. The limit of replacement is a question of how much original fabric is retained.

Why is a trial panel requested?

Because a material decision is verified on a surface, not on paper. An approved trial panel creates a shared reference for colour, texture, joint width and surface treatment, and shortens the arguments that follow.

External sources

  • Law No. 2863 on the Protection of Cultural and Natural Assets, Articles 9, 10, 11 and 12: https://www.mevzuat.gov.tr/mevzuat?MevzuatNo=2863&MevzuatTur=1&MevzuatTertip=5

  • Full text of Law No. 2863, PDF: https://www.mevzuat.gov.tr/MevzuatMetin/1.5.2863.pdf

  • Venice Charter, 1964, Articles 9, 10 and 12: https://www.icomos.org/images/DOCUMENTS/Charters/venice_e.pdf

  • Practical guidance on mortar repair, Historic England: https://historicengland.org.uk/images-books/publications/mortars-repairing-historic-buildings/

All sources accessed on 19 November 2026. Standard numbers and statutory text should be confirmed against the version in force on the transaction date, and the material decision should be signed by the project author.

A restrained next step

Prepare a one page definition sheet for the three material groups in the repair scope: the analysis summary of the existing material, the technical data of the candidate material, and the trial panel decision. That sheet becomes the shared language with suppliers and turns a material argument on site into a record keeping matter.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page